BasketMC

Not So Impossible Flashy Puzzles, Episode 41: The Witness

  • Published on

Episode 41 of The Witness goes straight back to the flashing panel that Episode 40 left unsolved, in the white room full of flowers. The whole video is spent on it: sorting out which dots belong together, testing what the sun allows, and drawing route after route. A minute before the end, the line goes through, and the next panel in the row lights up.

Back at the panel

After the edited-in title, the view is already on the grid with its purple left half and its color-shifting right half. "I already looked at this one a long time in the last episode," the commentary says. The first job is to pin down the colors by ignoring the flashing: "green green green green, okay, pink pink pink pink." Then the shapes: "This is a sun, so it needs to be with one pink," and "this is a pink L-shape, which can either be here, or it can be here."

Testing the rules

Most of the first half is experiments, each line drawn to see what complains. Some results surprise. "So these dots don't care if it's with the wrong color sun. I thought it did." The commentary sums up what the panel seems to allow: "dots can't be mixed together," but "you can have the wrong color sun hooked up." Even so, lines that look right keep failing, and "when they don't error the way you expect it kind of makes you confused a little bit."

A six by six grid panel, purple squares on the left half and yellow on the right, with dots, a star shape and a small block shape, and a cream and pale blue line drawn from the round start at the bottom left looping through the middle, beside a green panel crossed by a purple line

A look back along the row

Around twelve minutes the view swings left past the panels already solved, to explain them. "If it's the same color, they need to be grouped together and you can't have mixed colors." On the orange panels among the vines, the commentary points out "a sort of translation between the blinking and the non-blinking side."

Leafy vines with purple flowers beside an orange four by four panel with blue and yellow dots and a purple line drawn across it, and part of an orange and teal panel with a green line at the right

Back at the hard one, a new idea: "It might not be that you can't have them together at all, but you just can't have them outnumbered." It does not settle things. "I don't know how to solve this one. If this were somewhere else in the game, I would just return to it."

The solve

Then, mid-sentence: "Wait. Did I just solve it? Yes. Yes." A line runs from the start at the bottom left, winds through the lower half and climbs to the top right corner, and the next panel in the row lights up. The commentary explains it afterward: "I realized that I need to keep these two things put together."

The grid panel with a finished line, green in the lower left and purple further on, running from the round start at the bottom left up to the top right corner, beside a green panel with a purple line

Where it ends

The view moves up close to the newly lit panel, its squares glowing in every color at once. "I just noticed what's going to happen in the next one." The picture fades to the end card with that panel untried.

Close view of a five by five panel whose squares glow in mixed pink, yellow, blue, green and red against a rainbow-tinted frame, with no line drawn, and part of a pink panel with a blue line at the left edge